Archive pour March 2009

Legal framework of remixing: Techdirt makes the point

Remixing Is Creating And Original — It’s Not Just Derivative Copying At the beginning of the month we were one of the first to write about the amazing Thru-You ”album” created by a DJ named Kutiman, who took individual sounds off of YouTube and mixed them into a full album. I’ve always been a believer in the concept that [...]

Remixing Is Creating And Original — It’s Not Just Derivative Copying

At the beginning of the month we were one of the first to write about the amazing Thru-You ”album” created by a DJ named Kutiman, who took individual sounds off of YouTube and mixed them into a full album. I’ve always been a believer in the concept that remixing something is a creative endeavor in its own right, but I’d never seen the point driven home quite as clearly as in this album. Not suprisingly, Kutiman has received plenty of well-deserved attention for the project, and Wired is running a great interview with him that’s well worth reading. The idea that what he’s done is almost certainly illegal and copyright infringement (he seems incredulous at the idea) should be a clear indication that something is wrong with the current copyright regime. 

But, again, there’s this false belief out there that “remixing” is simply copying. But I defy anyone to explain how taking a simple kid playing a scale on a trumpet could become integral to an entire (great) funk song. Here’s the trumpet bit: And here’s the full song: Or how about this basic trombone solo becoming such a haunting and compelling part of this dub reggae song (trombone comes in at 42 seconds). Here’s the trombone: And here’s the full song: To say that’s “copying” or even just derivative is insulting to the amazing creativity and work of Kutiman to blend all these totally separate sounds into something amazing. Just as a musician plays notes on an instrument, Kutiman used YouTube as his instrument and created something amazing and wonderful… that probably breaks a ton of copyright laws. It’s difficult to see how anyone could claim that’s not a massive problem.

Permalink | Comments | Email This Story
En savoir plus…

Great piece of Remix Culture

Enjoy! Remix Culture

Enjoy! Remix Culture

Remix Culture

I have been listening to my iTunes on shuffle.  This is a “vertical” quasi-random search through a field of musicality bounded by the granularity of “a song” and by the volumnity of my personal collection.  It is thus a relatively “noisy experience” cultivated only by the degree to which I have been careful to weed [...]

I have been listening to my iTunes on shuffle.  This is a “vertical” quasi-random search through a field of musicality bounded by the granularity of “a song” and by the volumnity of my personal collection.  It is thus a relatively “noisy experience” cultivated only by the degree to which I have been careful to weed my personal iTunes library. 

Nonetheless it proves a quite effective co-party to thinking.  The possibility of converting this experience into a horizontal and cultivated or enriched experience is quite compelling.  If I could “play” a song that is of indefinite duration, is able to pull in fragments and references to other songs in a manner that is maximally sculpted to generate the right affect (given the potentials of the song and its conjunction in both time and space) and to deploy that in a manner that can be “branded” (e.g., by DJ or artist) to best match the engagement that I am trying to have – *this* would be intense.  And people would pay quite happily for this kind of experience.  

I am imaging an economy built on this “emergent” property of remix culture.  Ultimately, when people listen to music they rarely to the extreme listen to only one song.  Whether they are listening to background music in a restaurant, life music at a venue, dj’ed music at a club, their headphones at work or their stereo at home, they are engaging with a milieu of music defined by a temporal revealing and the complete integration of this revealed time of music is the “experience value” that really is felt.  The album is a very poor effort at this higher level effect – because its fixity (of musical selection and duration) means that it can only address a very small portion of the possible environments where the underlying music could be deployed.  The playlist kind of gets you there.  But it, too, lacks flexibility and even in an environment where people can share and compare playlists, the limits of your music collection and (frankly) your personal musicality, limit the potential of the playlist. 

This “higher order” economy should be more than adequate (particularly given the efficiencies we can discover in an effectively and fully deployed post-convergence environment) to generate all of the necessary elements.  That is, there should be enough money flowing through this system to adequately compensate both the “DJ” and the creators of the underlying music (as well as any necessary portions of the larger value chain).  One wrinkle that very much has to be worked-out is the issue of generating the maximum impression of the underlying music – so that it can convey the maximum intensity to the crafted environment.  Don’t Stop The Rock by the Chemical Brothers is playing right now.  This is good on just a musical level – but it is *better* because I know who they are, have a sense of what they are about and what their other music is – forging a much higher level of link-complexity in the overall experience.  At the *very* least, the “DJ”s have to be aware of what they are listening to/working with if simply to enable the ability to identify the components they want to integrate.

Jordan Greenhall


MXP4 powers new interactive and video games like music solutions for artists, fans, brands, labels and music distribution platforms : our patented technology allows to transform an MP3 into a game like experience for end users; our artist roaster to date include : Michael Jackson, Vitalic, Cindy Gomez, Soldout, Bassnectar, Sliimy, Ghostface Killah, Pink, Calvin Harris, Wax Tailor, Ophelie Winter, Nouvelle vague, Pony Pony Run Run, Dragonette, Midival Punditz, La Fouine, Birdy Nam Nam, Naive New Beaters, Stereos, Paramore, Jully Black, Pet Shop Boys, Molecule, Friends Of Friends, La Roux, The Sounds, Satine, David Guetta, The Grouch and Eligh, Chuckie, Britney Spears, The Grouch, Justin Nozuka, Jack Penate, Pep s, Kleerup, Dave Stewart, Esser, Passion pit, Amanda Blank, Data, Iliona Blanc, Speech Debelle, The Bravery, Bat For Lashes, Black and White Years, Basement Jaxx, Mark Knight, Coke, Ma Public Therapy, Black Kent, Danger, Nakidim, Lia Bowen, Make the girl dance, VV Brown, Ben Harper, Les chanteuses, Sarah Riani, Styrofoam Ones, Amen Birdmen, Laszlo Jones, Agnes, Kelis, Knaan, Audrey Katz, Stars, Digikid84, Big Boi, Knaan Music, Gotan Project...